Magic Story Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of magicstory.com

Magic StoryReviews of magicstory.com

Books & Magazines
Long Beach

Write a review Directions Website

4.6

Excellent

459 reviews

Magic Story4.6Excellent

Rating breakdown

Select a bar to see only those reviews.

What customers rate

Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.

About Magic Story

Magic Story creates personalized children’s books that turn every child into the hero of their own magical adventure. Our mission is to inspire creativity, build confidence, and foster emotional growth through stories that make reading an unforgettable family experience. Each book is tailored to your child’s name, likeness, and unique traits, featuring breathtaking illustrations and engaging themes such as Understanding Emotions and Facing Fears. Our stories help children develop life skills, build self-assurance, and spark their imagination while creating cherished family memories. Discover more at magicstory.com.

Magic Story (magicstory.com) has 459 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.

Also known as: magicstory.com
Website: magicstory.com
Category: Books & Magazines
Location: Long Beach
Listed on Rated Honest: 2026

More in Books & Magazines

Coruzant Technologies
Kansas City, MO
5.0Excellent108 reviews
Atticus Publishing
San Francisco, CA
4.9Excellent245 reviews
Georgetown Comics
Georgetown, KY
4.9Excellent435 reviews
BookTailor
Dover, DE
5.0Excellent95 reviews

Directions Write a review

Magic Story reviews

459 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Aleysha P.
Posted Feb 2, 2026
It's a delight to order books from…
It's a delight to order books from Magic Story. We've received one book so far (and a new one is on the way). The quality of the book was excellent, and the colors are vibrant and eye-catching. I was pleasantly surprised to receive the book so quickly after ordering, and my 6 year old loved seeing himself in a book! Thank you.
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
This made our day! We're thrilled that you were pleasantly surprised by the quality and how quickly it arrived. Those vibrant, eye-catching colors are one of our favorite parts too! And hearing that your 6-year-old loved seeing himself in the book is exactly what we're all about. We can't wait for the next one to arrive - get ready for another amazing adventure!
Report
Denise R.
Posted Feb 1, 2026
The story I love
The story I love
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
We're so glad you love this story, Denise! Your enthusiasm means the world to us. We can't wait for you to explore more amazing tales at Magic Story!
Report
Cozette L.
Posted Feb 1, 2026
I had an account already and have paid…
I had an account already and have paid for 2 books and have only received one.
Response from Magic Story· Apr 2, 2026
Cozette, we're so sorry to hear that — that's definitely not the experience we want for you! 💛 Please reach out to us directly at [email protected] with your order details and we'll make sure this gets sorted out right away. You deserve both of your books, and we want to make this right!
Report
Cris H.
Posted Jan 29, 2026
Had difficulty getting avatar right
Had difficulty getting avatar right; settled on a selection but only saw the cover page. Not sure I will continue until I see the rest of book.
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
Thank you for reaching out, Cris! We appreciate your feedback about the avatar selection and viewing experience. We hope you the book met your expectations when it arrived.
Report
Helen D.
Posted Jan 29, 2026
Bedtime
Love the story and photos, but prefer a story about bedtime NOT have the child eating candy. Grandson loves the Whale! His favorite word now. Age 2
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
Thank you for the wonderful review, Helen! We love that your grandson enjoys the story and the Whale is his favorite! We appreciate your feedback about the bedtime story content—it helps us create even better stories for families like yours!
Report
Kelly Y.
Posted Jan 28, 2026
My granddaughter is so excited getting her book every month.
I order a new book every month from Magic Story for my 4 yo granddaughter. She gets so excited when it comes in the mail and we have to read it right away. I like how the books discuss so many different issues that kids could be going through, in a nice and fun way. The pages are beautifully done and the star, my granddaughter, is adorable. It’s fun discussing the book, with my granddaughter, after reading it. Thank you for such wonderful books. Kelly A. Young
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
Kelly, this made our day! We absolutely love hearing that your 4-year-old granddaughter gets so excited when her monthly book arrives. Thank you for sharing how the books spark wonderful conversations between you both—that's the magic of storytelling!
Report
Lesa H.
Posted Jan 28, 2026
Children are cute but do not look…
Children are cute but do not look enough like picture
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
Thank you for the feedback, Lesa! We're continuously working to improve our product. We recently launched editing tools that allow you to fully customize your child's appearance. We hope this new feature allows you to achieve the resemblance you want.
Report
John A.
Posted Jan 13, 2026
Absolutely amazing experience
Absolutely amazing experience! My niece is over the moon with her storybook—her avatar looks just like her, which made it even more magical. Everything was seamless from start to finish: easy sign-up, simple photo upload, and clear progress tracking from creation to delivery. I love that you receive alerts when it’s time to continue the adventure, and I’ve already selected her next story. The book itself is beautifully made, with sturdy pages and a lovely, high-quality binding—it feels like a keepsake, not just a book. Truly a special gift. A new personalized book every month is such a fun and meaningful way to encourage reading. I can’t wait to see how the next one turns out! The pricing is perfect for what you receive, and the app is incredibly cool. She can download her story on her tablet, have it narrated, and enjoy additional content like music videos and a whole library of children’s songs. No other company comes close to Magic Story. I recommend it to everyone—it’s truly magical!
Response from Magic Story· Feb 9, 2026
John, your review absolutely made our day! We're thrilled your niece is over the moon with her storybook and that she's already picking her next story. Thank you for the wonderful feedback—Magic Story truly is magical when you see it through a child's eyes!
Report