David D.
Posted
Terrible Service
Terrible Service
Response from Sports Integrity· Jan 8, 2026
This was a fraudulent order flagged by our system and refunded!
Excellent
681 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
When shopping for fantastic sports collectibles and autographed sports memorabilia, come to Sports Integrity and you'll find exactly what you want!
Sports Integrity (sportsintegrity.com) has 681 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Showing 29 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
David D.
Posted
Terrible Service
Response from Sports Integrity· Jan 8, 2026
This was a fraudulent order flagged by our system and refunded!
JQ
Posted
I ordered an autograph. I recd a notice that it was shipping (which I assume means the shipping label was being printed), and then I got a notice that my order was being refunded. No explanation.
Response from Sports Integrity· Jan 8, 2026
Hello, we emailed you immediately notifying you of the issue after the label was printed and then we refunded you immediately thereafter
Dana T.
Posted
DNA tested! Seriously?! You guys. Come on. No one believes that. I stand by my review. I'll be happy to submit the photos of this guitar I purchased so everyone can see how bad it truly was.
Response from Sports Integrity· Apr 9, 2025
Yes PSADNA look them up if you know about autographs. This is a DUPLICATE REVIEW as well
Customer
Posted
I ordered a Johnny Unitas vintage Spalding football as a gift. It arrived deflated, and it will not inflate and hold inflation after multiple attempts. We have received zero assistance (even responses) from Sports Integrity in trying to resolve this.
Michael W.
Posted
This product is not what was advertised. It is nothing more than a cheap pease pf plastic. My son was expecting to be able to put it on but you can’t even do that because it is so fake. It is advertised as an authentic replica helmet but it is NOT. I paid good money for this item. So disappointed. It doesn’t even have Troy Polamalu number 43 on the back of the helmet. So bad, my advice to everyone out there not to buy anything from this company.
Response from Sports Integrity· Dec 17, 2024
You received EXACTLY what you purchased (showing the same helmet you ordered) which is a licensed Riddell Replica Steelers Helmet signed by Troy Polamlu. This is a collectible and not meant to be worn for safety reasons. It seems as though you think you purchased an Authentic On field helmet like Troy Polamalu wore including numbers on it? That is certainly not what we advertised. PLEASE send it back for a full refund. We would be more than happy to! This would indeed cost 3x more than what you paid.
Ashton Y.
Posted
not legit, no team symbol on jersey! need refund!
Response from Sports Integrity· Dec 11, 2024
You purchased a custom jersey. Below is the description of the jersey. It is clearly stated this has no team tags or emblems as also described by the title description and price! Description- Featured is a Saquon Barkley custom football jersey. This jersey features professionally sewn letters and numbers and is size XL. This jersey has no team tags or emblems and is intended as a sports collectible.
Jennifer D.
Posted
My order was canceled and I never received the item that they claimed was for sale. Horrifying and akin to false advertisement, for which the fine can be $40,000. You lost a customer and may have gained a plaintiff.
Response from Sports Integrity· Oct 9, 2024
Mr Rose passed away that evening and we oversold items in which we had to refund some. The orders were filled in order to when they were placed. This is NOT false advertising at all and your statement is totally false, threatening and defaming to us. You were also refunded immediately.
Christopher D.
Posted
I purchased two pictures which were both listed as the same size as I intended to hang them on the same wall. One is 3 inches larger. What is your return policy?