Michael R.
Posted
Delivered in a timely manner and…
Delivered in a timely manner and everything was correct that I ordered.
Poor
20 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Mycustomheart is listed under Jewelry & Watches.
Mycustomheart (mycustomheart.com) has 20 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.
Showing 6 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Michael R.
Posted
Delivered in a timely manner and everything was correct that I ordered.
Mari P.
Posted
The gift is completely amazing and exactly how I expected to be! My fiancé was completely caught off guard about it! And she loved it! Definitely will be doing business again! 10 out of 10 for the win! Thank you so much.
Response from Mycustomheart· Aug 17, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience! We’re so glad to hear your gift arrived just as you expected and that your fiancée loved the surprise. It’s always rewarding for our team to know we helped make a special moment even more memorable. We truly appreciate your support! ❤️
Sean B.
Posted
my girlfriend cried from their Valentine's Day gift (although she loves the sentimental stuff so I expected it). She wears the jewelry all the time and references to how cute the bear and heart container I got her are a lot. It's a custom product so I expected it to take some time but they got it to me 4 days after I placed the order. 5/5 experience, I will be shopping again for Mothers day. If your girl likes sentimental stuff and less about material things, she will probably love my custom heart
Response from Mycustomheart· Jun 26, 2026
Thank you so much for sharing this. We’re really happy to hear that the gift was so meaningful and that she loved the jewelry, bear, and heart container. That’s exactly the kind of reaction we hope our custom gifts can create. Thanks again for choosing us.
Martin G.
Posted
Girlfriend loved the gift. Shipment arrived on time. Feels like it is very high quality. Ring wasn't as shiny as in the picture, but still good. I'm glad I took the risk on them.
Nick
Posted
Got a gift bundle from My Custom Heart and it was great! Everything looked amazing, and the personal touches really made it special. My gf loved it and the whole thing was packaged perfectly. Definitely recommend if you want to give a unique and thoughtful gift
Stevie
Posted
My girlfriend absolutely loved what I ordered for her. The hygiene products smell amazing & the rose bear is a big recommend from me. If you think about ordering from here, I don’t see any reason why you shouldn’t. The cheap prices & amazing product don’t make sense to me. 10/10