Excellent
459 reviews
Magic StoryHonesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Magic Story creates personalized children’s books that turn every child into the hero of their own magical adventure. Our mission is to inspire creativity, build confidence, and foster emotional growth through stories that make reading an unforgettable family experience. Each book is tailored to your child’s name, likeness, and unique traits, featuring breathtaking illustrations and engaging themes such as Understanding Emotions and Facing Fears. Our stories help children develop life skills, build self-assurance, and spark their imagination while creating cherished family memories. Discover more at magicstory.com.
Magic Story (magicstory.com) has 459 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Showing 383 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Karen
Posted
The books turned out very well, thank you 😊 my son and his wife and my grandbaby love them 😊
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Thank you, Karen! Knowing the books went over well with your son, his wife and your grandbaby is exactly what we hope for. Thanks for trusting us with a family gift. — The Magic Story Team
Debbie B.
Posted
I ordered a previous book for my grandson who's 9 years old. At this age, Videogames are their life!! Now he reads more often ✅ When the book came, it was amazing!! From the Hard cover, illustrations and the character looked Exactly like my grandson! He loves it and so do I! Waiting on his next story! I've subscribed to get a book monthly and I think I'm more excited than him! 🥰
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Debbie, "now he reads more often" might be the best line in this entire review. That's the win we're really after. So glad the hardcover and the likeness lived up to it, and we're excited for you both to see what turns up next month. Thank you for subscribing. — The Magic Story Team
Hope K.
Posted
What a sweet book! The avatars look amazing!
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Thank you, Hope! The avatars are the piece we tinker with endlessly, so hearing they look amazing is the best kind of feedback. — The Magic Story Team
Cheryl
Posted
They didn’t love the story… sorry
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Cheryl, no need to apologize. That's genuinely useful for us to know. Not every story lands with every child, and we'd like the chance to find one that does. If you email our support team and let us know which book it was and what they're into, we'll help point you to a better fit. — The Magic Story Team
Genna
Posted
So I’ve signed up for the membership a few months ago. Our very first book “Even whales go to bed” came out absolutely perfect! Looking just like our son, great quality and arrived on time. Unfortunately the next book wasn’t as great. Back story our son has a beautiful birth mark near his left eye not on his nose but near the bridge unfortunately AI doesn’t recognize it most of the time. It will make a raised mole and put it EVERYWHERE BUT WHERE I TYPE TO ADD IT. The company replaced that book later telling me it’s not anymore they could do to guarantee we’d receive a book that has his birthmark. And yes his avatar is saved with it, go figure. After several emails asking about publishing etc. I received a live call from Jason who explained everything as well took accountability for the situation. He was a great help with the resolve going above and beyond! He published the Father’s Day book that I didn’t purchase having paused the membership. I really wanted the book for Father’s Day, he did explain it would unfortunately arrive after which was perfectly fine. The book arrived today and I’m elated! I quickly reached out to Jason informing him, to learn they had to individually do every page by hand to assure it was consistent and right ! This right here SPEAKS VOLUMES!! He also told me to reach out to him moving forward so he could proof it before being published to lessen the chance of it not being right. THIS IS TOP TIER!!! I’ll forever remember this and continue to purchase. It’s a lot when you’re a small business especially one that uses modern technology some times you can’t rely on technology but you should be able be able to rely on the company to resolve it. WHEN THEY’RE committed to their brand and customers they will always find resolutions. But ppl like him are an asset to have on their team. Thank you again Jason! Mrs.Burrell 💙
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Mrs. Burrell, thank you for writing all of this out. You had every reason to walk away after that second book, and instead you gave us the chance to make it right — that means a great deal to me personally. You're right that the technology will sometimes let us down; what shouldn't let you down is how we respond when it does. Your son's birthmark is part of who he is, and it belongs on the page. The offer stands: send anything my way before it goes to print and I'll proof it myself. Thank you for staying with us. — Jason, Magic Story
Cordelia W.
Posted
The book was beautifully done! The pictures are vibrant, and my granddaughter’s pictures came to life on every page! I can’t wait for the next issue.
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Cordelia, what a lovely thing to read. Seeing your granddaughter's pictures come to life on every page is exactly the moment we design for, and we're glad the color and print quality did it justice. The next issue is on its way. — The Magic Story Team
Kim
Posted
Daddy and daughter loved!
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Thank you, Kim! A book that both daddy and daughter want to read together is exactly what we're going for. So glad it was a hit. — The Magic Story Team
Mary-Frances S.
Posted
Our granddaughter loved seeing herself in the story!
Response from Magic Story· Sep 2, 2026
Thank you, Mary-Frances! That flash of recognition when a child finds herself in the story is our favorite part of this whole thing. So happy your granddaughter had it. — The Magic Story Team
