Excellent
57 reviews
Luther's DiamondsHonesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Luther’s Diamonds is a family-run custom jewelry studio based in Atlanta. We operate without a storefront, allowing us to offer direct wholesale pricing by eliminating retail markups. Every piece is designed and handcrafted to order in houses, specializing in custom engagement rings and fine jewelry made with lab-grown and natural diamonds, emeralds, sapphires, rubies, moissanite, and other precious gemstones. Because each piece is made specifically for the client, most projects require a minimum of 3–4 weeks. We focus on craftsmanship, transparency, and creating timeless jewelry built to last.
Luther's Diamonds (luthersdiamonds.com) has 57 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
57 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Kathelyn V.
Posted
My ring is absolutely beautiful, very professional and quick responses to any questions you may have
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Oct 24, 2025
Thank you, Kathelyn! We’re so glad you love how your ring turned out. Our team takes pride in quick, personal communication, so it means a lot that you felt supported through every step. 💍✨ — Jack + the Luther’s Diamonds team
Yolanda G.
Posted
We recently purchased the Arcfire Bond and Fusion Harmony rings as wedding rings and are so pleased with results. I was especially appreciative of the level of communication we had with Jack. He even sent us a video of the rings being made! Absolutely would recommend Luther's Diamonds to friends and anyone looking for their next jewelry purchase; we know we'll be coming back for more.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Oct 24, 2025
Yolanda, thank you so much — that focus and transparency are exactly what we care most about. Owning 100% of the process allows us to craft every ring exactly as envisioned, down to the smallest detail. It truly means the world to our team that you loved both your Arcfire Bond and Fusion Harmony rings. 💎 :) — Jack + the Luther’s Diamonds team
Daniela N.
Posted
Everything, Jack was amazing step by step of the process and the results are more that I was expecting.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Sep 6, 2025
Thank you so much, Daniela! We’re so glad the results were beyond your expectations. Your clear vision made the CAD confirmation process so smooth — it was a pleasure bringing it to life step by step with you. We truly appreciate your trust in us and are honored to be part of your journey. Knowing you felt guided and supported the whole way means the world. — Jack + the Luther’s Diamonds team ✨💍
Asger D.
Posted
I bought a custommade engagement ring. Very competetive price and service, quality and design is outstanding. Process took a bit longer than expected, but still deserves 5 stars.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Aug 19, 2025
Thank you so much for your kind words, Asger! We’re thrilled to hear that you loved the design, quality, and value of your custom engagement ring. Although the process took a little longer than expected, we’re so glad it was worth the wait — making every detail perfect is always our top priority. We especially loved incorporating the wave pattern on the band — such a meaningful touch! :) We truly appreciate your trust in us and are honored to be part of such a special piece. Wishing you all the best, and we’d be delighted to create more treasures for you in the future! — Jack + the Luther’s Diamonds team ✨💍
Lauren
Posted
Jack (the designer) was amazing to work with. My ring was made in rose gold and I even got to select my center stone emerald. The ring is absolutely beautiful in person and I will absolutely be ordering from Luther's for all future jewelry purchases.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Jul 24, 2025
Absolutely — making it perfect is our responsibility, and truly our passion! We loved your idea of choosing rose gold for the setting — it turned out beautifully. Thank you for trusting us to create something so special. We’re honored to be a part of your story, and we can’t wait to craft more pieces for you in the future :) With gratitude, Jack + the Luther’s Diamonds team
Aaron D. T.
Posted
I had a phenomenal experience with Luther's Diamonds from start to finish. Jack listened to everything I wanted and very patiently and professionally answered all of my questions and concerns. The ring came out exactly as hoped for and we could not be happier with it. In fact, I'll be placing a new order for another custom piece very soon.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Jul 24, 2025
Aaron, thank you so much for your incredible words — it means the world to us. It was an absolute pleasure working with you to bring your vision to life, and I’m so glad the final piece lived up to everything you hoped for. Knowing that you’ll be returning for another custom piece is the highest compliment we could receive. From all of us at Luther’s Diamonds, thank you for trusting us with something so meaningful. We can’t wait to create your next one ✨💎 Warmly, Jack + the Luther’s team
Olivia B.
Posted
Very slow shipping with multiple delays; I reached out multiple times for updates and didn't hear anything back until I mentioned doing a chargeback. Item was supposed to be a gift, but arrived too late for the occasion. Website says they are based in South Korea, but my item shipped from China. Additionally, it was a different color of gold than described (rose gold instead of yellow. After all the delays and slow responses, I didn't want to risk a return.
Response from Luther's Diamonds· Jul 16, 2025
Hi Olivia, We're so sorry to hear about your experience. While we do have a fulfillment warehouse in China to expedite international orders, our team and design headquarters are proudly based in South Korea. We sincerely apologize for the shipping delays and lack of timely updates. That is not the standard we hold ourselves to. Regarding the gold color — we’re more than happy to offer a replacement in yellow gold at no cost to you. Just reach out to our support team directly and we’ll make it right. We truly value your feedback and appreciate the opportunity to improve. Thank you for your patience.
Lovee C.
Posted
Jake is a total rockstar! He guided me through the process of ordering my ring, and kept me updated during the process. Even when I had a slight issue with the shipping process (totally my fault), he did everything that he could to make the process as smooth as possible. Once I saw the ring, it exceeded my expectations 😭. It's way more beautiful in person. It shines so beautifully, even from the top view! (i did not expect that!). I also had a citrine stone inlay added to my ring and it's does not affect how comfortable the ring is. The ring also has a nice weight to it. I recommend Luther's Diamonds to everyone 1000%!!!! Thank you so much 🥰
Response from Luther's Diamonds· May 19, 2025
Hi Lovee, Wow, thank you so much for this amazing review! Jack and the whole team are thrilled to hear that your experience was smooth and enjoyable—even when unexpected hiccups happened. We’re so happy your ring exceeded your expectations and that the citrine inlay feels just right :) Your recommendation means the world to us, and we can’t wait to help you (or anyone you send our way) with future pieces! Thanks again for trusting Luther’s Diamonds! 💎✨ Warmest regards, The Luther’s Diamonds Team
