Jay
Posted
This is my favorite mascara…
I found the mascara i like on this site, they don't always have it in my drug store. It took a little longer to be delivered this time. In the past it was delivered very quickly.
Excellent
590 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
BuyMeBeauty.com is the #1 source for discontinued and discounted makeup, beauty products, and cosmetics from brands like Revlon, Loreal, Maybelline, and Almay.
BuyMeBeauty (buymebeauty.com) has 590 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
Showing 24 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
Jay
Posted
I found the mascara i like on this site, they don't always have it in my drug store. It took a little longer to be delivered this time. In the past it was delivered very quickly.
MKH
Posted
Good color and texture
Nancy E.
Posted
So glad they have what I needed that I couldn’t find anywhere else ! Faster shipping would have made it a 5 star :)
Roberto V.
Posted
Exelente muy bueno
Response from BuyMeBeauty· Dec 11, 2025
Thank you for your review! We’re happy to hear you had a great experience, and we appreciate your feedback. We hope to earn that fifth star next time you shop with us! – BuyMeBeauty Customer Care Team
Kaye
Posted
The eyeliners are fine and I like that there is a brown/black and a black.
Response from BuyMeBeauty· Oct 20, 2025
Hello Kaye, Thank you for your review! We’re glad to hear you’re enjoying the eyeliners and appreciate the feedback about the dual shades. We hope to earn that fifth star next time! 💫 — The BuyMeBeauty Team
Linda M.
Posted
Product was old.. both items were dried out and unusable I did hear from the company and they promptly gave me a full refund. I will definitely try them again.
Response from BuyMeBeauty· Oct 20, 2025
Hello Linda, We’re very sorry to hear that the items you received did not meet expectations. While we haven’t received similar reports about this product, we take your feedback seriously and want to make it right. Someone from our customer service team will be reaching out to you directly to review the order and find the best solution. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. — The BuyMeBeauty Team
Pamela F.
Posted
I would have preferred some communication about my purchase being shipped and/or being delivered. I was getting very nervous, as it took 9 days to receive my order. I guess I am used to the super fast experience with Amazon. I am very pleased with the products I received, and thankful that you provided what I have looked for everywhere.
Response from BuyMeBeauty· Oct 8, 2025
Hi Pamela, Thank you so much for your honest feedback — and for giving us the chance to find those hard-to-find favorites for you! We completely understand that delivery times can feel long compared to Amazon’s pace, and we’re always working to improve our communication and shipping updates. We’re so glad to hear you loved your products, and we truly appreciate your patience and support. -BuyMeBeauty Team
Cheryl S.
Posted
The best and most important thing is that Baby Lips is the very best product ever!! I was introduced to it by a friend, and I've used it ever since...AND recommended it to others, who also love it. The reason I didn't give it 5 stars is the length of time it takes to get it here!! But that just means I need to order ahead of when I need it!!