customer
Posted
Dead website???
Can't get into my account. password reset is not functioning.
Response from Gun Deals· Oct 20, 2026
Email [email protected] - They can definitely help you! I let them know just now as well.

Excellent
37 reviews
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Dissolved in 2025
Gun Deals (americanguntrader.com) has 37 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
37 approved reviews, newest moderated first
customer
Posted
Can't get into my account. password reset is not functioning.
Response from Gun Deals· Oct 20, 2026
Email [email protected] - They can definitely help you! I let them know just now as well.
Michael M.
Posted
I had a technical issue getting set up in the website, Their Technical was second to None! The responded very quickly and gut thing resolved verry efficiently! All is now working Great. I would recommend them as a Trusted Business Partner any day! Once in things were easy to navigate and figure out! I think this will become a Great Venue for Gun Buyers and sellers to come together!
customer
Posted
Easy so far!
Dirk S.
Posted
Easy peasy to get started. Let you know better when my gun sells.
IM N.
Posted
Easy to list an item. No surprises or "fees"... Finally, a site with NO hoops to jump through!
Dominic B.
Posted
Fast and easy setup seems like a great firearm friendly environment.
Roy F.
Posted
It was easy to list an item. However, it's obvious that you concentrate on FFLs and gun sales. I am not an FFL, I deal in parts and accessories. I don't know how much traffic my items will get.
Response from Gun Deals· Aug 22, 2026
Roy, that is real, actionable feedback, and it means a lot. 1) I just granted your account a free boost. Use that to get one of your accessories listings reaching more folks. 2) Consider featuring some higher ticket (optics, etc) in our newsletter! 3) The platform add position (goes to YOUR website, or AGT profile to show your entire catalog) is shown on the desktop homepage, and in 4 newsletters (weekly, for one month) and it's available in September. You can grab it here: https://americanguntrader.com/partners 4) The team is now brainstorming some other ways we could "spotlight" accessories on the platform to get vendors like yourself more reach. You gave some really good feedback, at a good time, so thanks a lot.
Beyonders
Posted
BEWARE. This site is a cesspool for scammers. Found a “seller” by the name of (Shull-precission) and provided to gain my trust by sending a fake FFL under CJ Armory and survival and a Fake FFL dealer named Jared Garrison (possible stolen identity). Guy can’t be that stupid to send a picture of his I.d. But he Sent a picture of “himself” with all the doctored info. Well after an entire ordeal and going against my gut, I sent the money & the so call seller claimed to have sent the gun. They Provided a shipping tracking number and everything on a fake shipping site (proper shipper). Well long story short this scammer ghosted me and took down his fake site on this platform. Erased his number and after many attempts to contact AGT about this, zero response and in fact after many requests for help, & to give them a heads up, there was zero response and the requests all got deleted. I browsed the site today and they’re still operating on this platform but under different names. $900 gone and I will warn all of you DO NOT USE THIS SITE. It’s a great site for scammers to play out their elaborate schemes. God bless
Response from Gun Deals· Aug 20, 2026
1) I'm so sorry to hear you've had a bad experience. AGT has built in Verified FFL rails, that are required. Going around the Verified FFL Selector is prohibited on the site. This is on our guides, and terms of service - we are now actively investigating your specific case. How to choose an FFL: https://americanguntrader.com/help/messaging/choosing-an-ffl 2) Did you message the official @support chat on AGT? We haven't received any support requests regarding this matter. Send me an email at [email protected] anytime, and we'll try to make this right with you.