Great
52 reviews
SurprisechestHonesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
NOW FREE SHIPPING! Set sail for instant fun. Captain Mystery packed this chest with at least 24 individually wrapped surprises, each one a spark for your party, game night, or gift exchange. No two chests are the same. Your chest arrives gift ready in our signature full color SurpriseChest box that looks like real treasure.Perfect for:Birthdays and office shenanigansWhite elephant, reverse white elephant, or gift rouletteFamily game night, dorm hangouts, holiday chaosFilled with:Lost MailUnclaimed packagesUndeliverable mailReturnsWho knows whatWhat's Inside?Each chest is a true mystery, even to us. We do not open or pre-sort the individual packages. All items are wrapped as received. Actual contents vary, and may include:Undeliverable packagesUnclaimed packagesOverstock productsCustomer returnsCancelled ordersMost items arrive in their original or shipper packaging. Some packages may show box or label wear. That unpredictability is part of the fun.
Surprisechest (surprisechest.com) has 52 customer reviews on Rated Honest, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Showing 37 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Courtney
Posted
It’s fun to get these boxes. Lots of stuff inside and you never know what you’ll get. I’ve gotten weird random stuff, clothes, perfumes, pickleball paddles(worth more than what I paid for the box) rolls of stamps(100 on each roll) shoes, just so much stuff. Most can be resold, kept other stuff. Always super fast shipping too.
Kerrie R.
Posted
The all around experience was great ! The quality and mystery was great for my son and I we,had a blast !! Home from college but felt like we were kids at Christmas!!
Catherine M.
Posted
Me and my grandkids loved them!
Response from Surprisechest· May 11, 2026
We are so glad! We love hearing about people enjoying our chests!
Amy
Posted
So much fun and lots of good stuff!!!
Aprille G.
Posted
So, to start off, it comes in a really neat box that the grandbabies absconded with as soon as it was empty lol! I was honesly shocked when I looked up the values of some of the items. One pair of sneakers was $240!! There was a super fancy gown, gel nail polish set, a toy that sells for $150 at Best Buy which had me blinking because I was going to just give it to the boys... and several other items that had a weirdly high initial purchase price! There was actually fewer weird items in this one than a box I had gotten from another site. While I am guessing my experience with the value of the items I received is not necessesarily the norm, I am super happy with my experience and will def be purchasing again! <3
